The short answer
No single conservatory roof system wins outright; the best one is whichever matches the way you live in the room and the load your frame will bear.
An insulated solid roof is best for year-round comfort, glass is best for daylight, and polycarbonate is best when the budget is tight.
Whichever type you pick, the quality of the survey and fitting matters as much as the product itself.
Search for the best conservatory roof system and you will find plenty of firms keen to tell you it is whichever one they sell. The honest answer is less tidy. Each system is the best at something, and the right one for you depends on a few questions only you can answer.
Start with how you use the room
Before comparing products, think back over the past year. Which months did you shut the door on that room, and what drove you out?
- Sweltering in June, freezing by December. This points firmly at an insulated solid roof, sometimes called a warm roof.
- Fine most of the year, but tired and leaky. A modern glass roof will probably give you what you want without changing the character of the room.
- Used as a utility room or a cut-through to the garden. New polycarbonate sheets may be all it needs.
Recognise yourself in more than one? Most people do, and plenty settle on a middle way, like tiles with a lantern for daylight.
The three systems, compared
Here is how they stack up on the things people notice after living with them. These are general traits rather than lab results.
| Solid warm roof | Glass | Polycarbonate | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Comfort across the year | Best | Middling | Weakest |
| Light from above | Least, unless you add a lantern | Most | Good, softened |
| Noise in a downpour | Hushed | Muted | Drums |
| Load on the frame | Most | Middling | Least |
| Building regulations | Normally needed | Often not | Often not |
| Guide price, medium room (thousands) | £8k to £12k | £3.5k to £5k | £2.5k to £4k |
Those figures come from our UK-wide bands for a room roughly 3.5 metres each way. Nothing has been adjusted for Wolverhampton, and none of it is a quote. We estimated the polycarbonate band ourselves, pitching it just under glass.
Solid warm roofs
A solid roof is built much like a small house roof: a structure of timber or lightweight beams, a thick layer of insulation, then lightweight tiles or slate-look panels outside and a plastered ceiling inside. It is the system that does most for comfort and noise.
The trade-offs are weight, cost and paperwork. As LABC explains, insulating and roofing over a conservatory strips its building regulations exemption, which means an application and an inspector satisfied that the frame and footings can bear it. Our regs page explains how that works with City of Wolverhampton Council.
Glass roofs
Modern glass roofs use sealed double-glazed units, often with coatings that reduce glare and some of the sun’s heat. They keep the conservatory feeling like a conservatory.
You may find a south-facing glass roof still gets warm on a bright afternoon, and it will never hold heat as well as an insulated roof. But if daylight is the point of the room, nothing else gives you as much.
Polycarbonate
Polycarbonate is the multi-wall plastic sheeting on many conservatories built from the 1990s onwards. New sheets swapped in for yellowed old ones, with the frame left as it is, cost the least of any option and weigh the least too.
It is also the loudest in rain and does the least to control temperature. For a room you mainly walk through, that may not matter.
A worked example from the Black Country
Picture two neighbours on the same street in Tettenhall. One uses her conservatory as a dining room all year and is fed up with it being unusable in January. The other grows tomatoes and chillies in his and mostly wants it bright.
For the first, a solid roof with a lantern is the obvious fit, budget allowing. For the second, a glass roof keeps what he values while fixing the leaks. Same street, same house type, different best system. If either lives in Tettenhall Greens or Tettenhall Wood, both conservation areas, a quick check with the council comes first.
What matters as much as the system
A well-chosen roof badly fitted will disappoint you. Look for a firm that surveys the frame before quoting, explains who is handling building control, and tells you in writing what is and is not included. Our post on questions to ask a conservatory roof installer has a list to take with you.
For prices by size, the calculator gives a range in a few clicks, and the Conservatory Roofs Wolverhampton homepage has a quick overview of all three systems.
Where this comes from
Rules and figures above are drawn from the pages below, which open in a new tab.
