Tiled, solid warm roof
You may have been told a solid roof is just a conservatory with a lid on. Done properly, it is closer to a small single-storey extension: a timber or lightweight frame, a thick layer of insulation, lightweight tiles or slates on top and a plastered ceiling underneath.
Good at
Temperature. Warmth stays in through the colder months and the midsummer glare stays out, so the room stops lurching from one extreme to the other.
Quiet. Rain and hail become a distant patter rather than a drum roll.
Looks. Tiles can be picked to sit alongside the main house roof, which matters on a street of slate and clay tile.
Less good at
Light. The sky above disappears. Building in a lantern, or two or three glazed panels, wins some of it back.
Weight and paperwork. It is far heavier than glass, and it normally needs building regulations approval, so there is a survey and an application before work starts.
Cost. It is the dearest of the three by a wide margin.
Double-glazed glass
Today’s glass roofs bear little resemblance to the thin single glazing on early conservatories. Sealed double units with special coatings knock back glare and part of the sun’s heat, and some are designed so the rain rinses them clean.
Good at
Daylight. Nothing beats it for light. If the room is where you read, grow plants or watch the garden, this keeps that.
Sound. Noticeably quieter than polycarbonate sheets in heavy rain.
Simpler sign-off. Because the roof stays glazed, the conservatory can often stay exempt from building regulations, provided the other conditions are still met.
Less good at
Heat. Even good glass lets a lot of warmth through on a sunny afternoon, and lets it out again on a frosty night.
Weight. Glass units are heavier than sheets, so the frame still needs a look.
Privacy. If you are overlooked by upstairs windows next door, a clear roof does nothing about it.
Polycarbonate, new sheets
Polycarbonate is the multi-wall plastic sheeting found on a great many conservatories built in the 1990s and 2000s. Replacing tired, yellowed sheets with new ones in the same frame is usually the quickest and lowest-cost fix.
Good at
Price. The least expensive way to deal with a roof that leaks or has gone cloudy.
Light weight. It asks the least of the frame, so an older structure is less likely to need work.
Speed. A straight sheet swap is a short job compared with building a solid roof.
Less good at
Noise. Rain is loud on it, especially on thinner sheets.
Comfort. It does the least to keep the room warm in winter or cool in summer.
Ageing. Sheets discolour over the years, which is often why people are looking at a new roof in the first place.
All three in one table
Here are the same three roofs compared on the things people tend to notice once they have lived with them. These are general traits, not test results, and a particular product or fitting can move any of them.
| Compared on | Solid, tiled | Glass | Polycarbonate |
|---|
| Light from above | Little, unless you add a lantern | The most | Good, softened |
|---|
| Summer heat | Best kept out | Can run warm | Often runs hot |
|---|
| Winter warmth | Best kept in | Middling | Poor |
|---|
| Sound of heavy rain | Barely there | A soft patter | A drum roll |
|---|
| Weight on the frame | By far the most | In between | Very little |
|---|
| Building regulations | Normally needed | Often not, if still a true conservatory | Often not, if still a true conservatory |
|---|
| Lifespan | Longest | Long | Shortest |
|---|
If two of these rows matter far more to you than the rest, that usually settles it. Prices for each are on the Wolverhampton prices page.
The frame question nobody should skip
Here is the part that catches people out. A conservatory frame and base were designed for the roof that was put on originally, usually glass or polycarbonate. Swap that for tiles and insulation and you are asking the same structure to carry a good deal more.
LABC, the umbrella for local authority building control, makes it plain that the inspector will want evidence that what is already there (frames, door supports, footings) can bear a solid roof's extra weight. A careful fitter will look at the same things before quoting, and may suggest extra posts, a stronger beam around the top of the frame or, now and then, starting again with the walls.
Are your frames sagging, are doors sticking, or are there cracks in the dwarf wall? Mention it when you ask for quotes. It is far cheaper to find out at survey than halfway through the job.
Which roof for which Wolverhampton house?
Wolverhampton's older streets give you a feel for what tends to work. The council's appraisal of the Park conservation area describes stuccoed villas from about 1840, late-Victorian and Edwardian houses built after West Park opened in 1881, and semis from the 1920s and 1930s, mostly in red brick with Welsh slate or plain clay tile roofs.
Next to houses of that kind, a solid roof in grey slate-effect or a warm clay-coloured tile can look as though it was always meant to be there. A glass roof suits a conservatory tucked away at the back of a garden that gets morning sun, where light matters more than heat. Polycarbonate makes sense where the room is a lean-to utility space and spending thousands on it is hard to justify.
Listed house? Conservation area? One of the Article 4 streets by the park? Any of those, and the regs page is your next stop before choosing.